Here's an engaging story inspired by a true case to answer a key question for successful business owners:

Does the time ever run out on when you can sue someone for damages arising from a breach of contract?

Don’t Wait to Litigate

In the town of Lakewood, New Jersey, Dr. Gerald Timmons was a well-known orthopedic surgeon with a reputation for excellence—and persistence. But it was that persistence that would lead him into a seven-year tangle of legal drama with a former patient, Sophia Park, and a series of missed opportunities.

It all began on a rainy afternoon in November 2009 when Sophia’s car hydroplaned on the slippery streets of Lakewood, crashing into a utility pole. The injuries weren’t life-threatening, but her shoulder was in bad shape, and surgery was inevitable. Dr. Timmons, who ran a high-end private practice, assured her she’d be back to yoga in no time. Sophia signed all the necessary paperwork, including an “Agreement for Payment of Outstanding Bills” and a “Release and Assignment of Benefits.” These documents, as far as Dr. Timmons was concerned, ensured his payment—eventually.

Sophia's insurance company, however, had other ideas. By early 2010, Dr. Timmons found himself chasing them for payment. He filed a no-fault PIP arbitration against Sophia’s insurer, believing it would resolve the issue. The arbitration dragged on for nearly three years, eventually settling in December 2012. Unfortunately for Dr. Timmons, invoices for services rendered between January 2011 and May 2012 were excluded from the settlement. He was frustrated but optimistic.

“These things take time,” he told his office manager. “The system works eventually.”

But optimism turned into irritation when a second arbitration found that the excluded invoices were barred under something called the “entire controversy doctrine.” To a layperson, it sounded like legal jargon; to Dr. Timmons, it sounded like money slipping through his fingers. Still, he decided not to appeal. Instead, he pivoted.

In 2016, Dr. Timmons filed a breach of contract lawsuit against Sophia herself, seeking payment for the excluded invoices. But as the court date approached, his attorney advised him to drop the case voluntarily, believing it might be better handled another way. Dr. Timmons reluctantly agreed.

For three years, he let the matter rest. But in December 2019, with his practice facing financial pressures and memories of Sophia's unpaid bills gnawing at him, Dr. Timmons decided to try again. He filed yet another complaint for the same invoices, convinced that the terms of the 2009 agreement would protect his claim.

Sophia, now a local florist and mother of two, was stunned to receive the court summons. She had assumed the matter was long over, buried in the bureaucratic graveyard of insurance disputes. But her attorney, a sharp litigator named Maya Chen, assured her there was nothing to worry about.

“Dr. Timmons is going to run into the same problems he ran into before,” Maya said. “The law hasn’t changed.”

And she was right. The court ruled against Dr. Timmons yet again. This time, the judge laid it out plainly: the entire controversy doctrine barred the claim. Moreover, the statute of limitations had long since expired. Dr. Timmons’ cause of action had accrued back in 2012 when the insurance company refused to pay the disputed invoices. Seven years later was simply too late.

Standing in the courthouse lobby after the ruling, Dr. Timmons felt a mix of disbelief and exhaustion. Maya, who had stayed behind to collect paperwork, offered him a small, empathetic smile as she passed by.

“Sometimes it’s better to let it go,” she said gently.

For Dr. Timmons, the lesson was bittersweet. The pursuit of what he believed was right had consumed years of his professional life, but the system he had trusted to deliver justice had instead delivered frustration. As he walked back to his car, he resolved to focus on the patients who still needed him—and to leave Sophia Park, and her unpaid invoices, in the past.

Sophia, meanwhile, returned to her flower shop and her life, relieved that her chapter with Dr. Timmons was finally closed. And in the end, both learned something about the weight of unfinished business — and the cost of trying to settle old scores.

Takeaways for Business Owners

So, dear business owners and managers,

Remember: Timeliness is key in legal matters. If you believe you have a valid claim, act promptly to avoid running afoul of statutes of limitations or other procedural bars. Staying proactive and consulting with a skilled attorney early can save you years of frustration and prevent costly mistakes.

This story is based on a real court case, with names and details modified for clarity and confidentiality. The legal principles remain the same, providing important lessons for business owners facing similar situations.

Are you wondering about any of the issues mentioned above? Please email us at info@wilkinsonlawllc.com or call (732) 410-7595 for assistance.

At Wilkinson Law, we give business owners the clarity they need to fund, grow, protect, and sell their businesses. We are trustworthy business advisors keeping your business on TRACK: Trustworthy. Reliable. Available. Caring. Knowledgeable.®