Here's a story inspired by a real case to answer an important question for business owners:
What good are favorable terms in a business agreement
if the other party can change them without your consent?
The Deal That Came With an Eraser
$11,600,000.
Frank Delaney stared at the figure on his computer screen.
He checked the numbers again, then called his accountant.
"Rosa, remember that investment I made with Peter?"
"The three million?"
"Eleven point six million now."
"Wonderful. Is it in your bank account?"
"Not yet. But Peter promised I could cash out after five years."
Rosa paused.
"Frank, is that promise in writing?"
Frank suddenly remembered why he preferred talking to Peter.
The two men had been friends for over twenty years. They'd played golf together, attended family celebrations, and occasionally invested in each other's business ventures.
In November 2012, Peter Alden had approached Frank with an opportunity involving Northstar Technologies, a publicly traded company.
Peter wanted Frank to invest $3 million through Graybridge Capital LLC, a Delaware company he controlled.
Over lunch in White Plains, New York, Frank raised a concern.
"What if I want out?"
Peter explained that if Northstar's stock reached $50 a share, Graybridge would sell its holdings and distribute Frank's portion.
"And if it doesn't?"
"After five years, I'll make sure you have an opportunity to cash out based on what your investment is worth."
"Five years?"
"Five."
Frank shook his hand.
He wired $1.5 million that November and another $1.5 million the following October.
What Frank didn't realize was that Graybridge's operating agreement gave Peter the authority to amend it without his consent.
In June 2014, Peter signed an amended agreement covering the company's management, distributions, and ownership rights. It also replaced earlier written and verbal agreements concerning those matters.
Frank's promised exit arrangement wasn't preserved.
Then came November 2017.
Frank arrived at Peter's office with a folder containing his investment figures.
"Well," Peter said, looking at the valuation, "you've done pretty well."
"Not bad for five years."
Peter smiled.
Frank placed the folder on the desk.
"So, let's talk about getting me out."
The smile faded.
"Frank, it's not quite that simple."
"What isn't?"
"Getting you out of Graybridge."
Frank pulled his chair closer.
"Peter, remember that lunch? You said five years. If the stock didn't reach fifty, you'd give me a way out."
"I remember."
"Good. Because the stock didn't reach fifty, and it's been five years."
Peter leaned back.
"We need to look at what the company's operating agreement allows."
Frank stared at him.
"Your operating agreement? Peter, we had an agreement before I gave you the money."
"I understand."
"Then what's the problem?"
Peter didn't give him the answer he'd come for.
Frank had walked into that office expecting to discuss how he would receive the value of his investment. He left wondering whether he would receive it at all.
When the promised exit failed to materialize, Frank hired a lawyer.
He wanted Peter to buy his interest for approximately $11.6 million.
But Peter's lawyers pointed to the amended operating agreement.
Frank was furious.
"He changed that agreement after I invested! I never even signed the amendment!"
Unfortunately for Frank, that wasn't enough.
The dispute eventually reached New York's highest court.
When the judgment finally came, Frank learned something he hadn't expected.
He didn't need to sign the amended operating agreement to be bound by it. As a member of Graybridge, he was subject to its terms. And because Peter had the authority to change those terms, the earlier promise was no longer enforceable.
His lawsuit was dismissed.
Frank still owned his investment. But the exit he'd negotiated before handing over $3 million? He couldn't enforce it.
The worst part was that Frank had seen the problem coming.
Five years earlier, he'd sat across from Peter, worried about how he'd get his money out. He'd asked the right question and negotiated an answer.
He just hadn't made sure Peter couldn't change that answer once the money was his.
Takeaway for Business Owners
So, dear business owners, negotiating favorable terms is only half the job. Before committing your money or fulfilling your obligations, understand who can change those terms and whether your consent is required. The most important provision in your agreement may be the one that determines who has the power to rewrite all the others.
This story is based on a real court case, with names and details modified for clarity and confidentiality. The legal principles remain the same, providing important lessons for business owners facing similar situations.
Are you wondering about any of the issues mentioned above? Please email us at info@wilkinsonlawllc.com or call (732) 410-7595 for assistance.
At Wilkinson Law, we give business owners the clarity they need to fund, grow, protect, and sell their businesses. We are trustworthy business advisors keeping your business on TRACK: Trustworthy. Reliable. Available. Caring. Knowledgeable.®
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, or other professional advice. The information presented may not apply to your particular circumstances and may be affected by changes in applicable law or other developments after the date of publication. You should not act or refrain from acting based on this article without consulting appropriate professional advisers regarding your specific circumstances. Reading this article, communicating with Wilkinson Law LLC, or submitting information through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship with Wilkinson Law LLC is established only through a written engagement agreement between the firm and the client.